Case study

The Brambleford vaccine batch

Check a new batch of a vaccine: unsatisfactory doses among 10 and 20 as binomials, then the time a dose takes to work as a normal.

Draws on 5. The binomial distribution, 7. The normal distribution, 11. Student's t and confidence intervals

Step 1The batch

Brambleford, a vaccine maker, must check a new batch before it is released. From earlier batches, a dose is twice as likely to work satisfactorily as not, so the probability p that a dose is unsatisfactory solves \(p + 2p = 1\): \(p = \tfrac{1}{3}\). The quality team looks at the batch three ways: 10 doses, then 20 doses for a city's health workers, then the time 50 doses take to work.

Step 2Ten doses

Each dose works or not, independently, with the same p, and the team counts the unsatisfactory ones among 10: \(X \sim B(10, \tfrac{1}{3})\). Keep p as the fraction 1/3; rounding it to 0.33 shifts every answer (chapter 5).

k = 3

P(X ≤ 3) = 0.5593

Open this set-up in the explorer
Unsatisfactory doses among 10, B(10, 1/3), with P(X ≤ 3) shaded

Exactly three unsatisfactory

What is the probability that exactly 3 of the 10 doses are unsatisfactory?

Your answer
A decimal or a fraction; within 0.0001 of the answer counts as right.

Nine or ten work

What is the probability that more than 8 of the 10 doses work satisfactorily?

Your answer
A decimal or a fraction; within 0.0001 of the answer counts as right.

Step 3Twenty doses for a city

A city asks for 20 doses for its health workers. Now \(X \sim B(20, \tfrac{1}{3})\), with a mean of \(\tfrac{20}{3} = 6.67\) unsatisfactory doses.

k = 5

P(X ≤ 5) = 0.2972

Open this set-up in the explorer
Unsatisfactory doses among 20, B(20, 1/3), with P(X ≤ 5) shaded

More than half unsatisfactory

What is the probability that at least 11 of the 20 doses are unsatisfactory?

Your answer
A decimal or a fraction; within 0.0001 of the answer counts as right.

At least thirteen work

What is the probability that at least 13 of the 20 doses work satisfactorily?

Your answer
A decimal or a fraction; within 0.0001 of the answer counts as right.

Step 4The time a dose takes to work

Fifty volunteers each receive a dose (the lab's dose-times.csv). Their times have a mean of 13.39 hours and a standard deviation of 4.76 hours, and the histogram is roughly a bell, so the team models a dose's time as \(N(13.39, 4.76)\).

50 values · mean 13.392 · standard deviation 4.758 · fitted N(μ = 13.392, σ = 4.758)

Open in the data-fit labDownload dose-times.csv
The hours 50 doses took to work, with the normal N(13.39, 4.76)

Between 10 and 15 hours

Using the model \(N(13.39, 4.76)\), what is the probability that a dose takes between 10 and 15 hours to work?

Your answer
A decimal or a fraction; within 0.0001 of the answer counts as right.

Nine doses in ten

Using the model \(N(13.39, 4.76)\), within how many hours do 90 % of doses work (the 90th percentile, to four decimals)?

Your answer
A decimal or a fraction; within 0.0001 of the answer counts as right.

Step 5The mean time, with its uncertainty

The model describes single doses. For the batch's mean time to effect, chapter 11's t interval applies: with n = 50, \(t^* = 2.0096\), and the 95 % interval is 13.39 ± 1.35 hours, from 12.04 to 14.74 hours. Single doses vary far more: the model puts one dose in ten beyond 19.49 hours.

Try this Build the interval in the confidence interval builder, and see how it narrows with more volunteers.
Remember: With \(p = \tfrac{1}{3}\), 3 unsatisfactory doses in 10 is the likeliest count (0.2601), and 11 or more in 20 would be rare (0.0376). A dose takes 13.39 hours on average, with a 95 % interval for the mean of 12.04 to 14.74 hours, and nine doses in ten work within 19.49 hours.
An unhandled error has occurred. Reload 🗙

Reconnecting…

Your connection to Introduction to Probability Lab dropped, probably a Wi-Fi blip. Hold on while it reconnects.

The connection could not be restored. The page will reload in a few seconds.